2019
| Murphy's Debt - Short Contemporary Romance | Cowboy's Promise - Short Contemporary Romance | |
| Golden Heart, finalist | Cleveland Rocks, finalist | |
| Maggie, finalist | ||
| Lone Star, finalist | ||
| Indiana Golden Opportunity, finalist | ||
| Tara, finalist |
2018
| Murphy's Debt - Series/Category |
| Maggie, first place |
2017
| Home to Stay - Series/Category | A Risk Worth Taking - Single Title | Bad Medicine |
| Maggie, honorable mention | Maggie, third place | Ignite the Flame, third place |
| Rebecca, finalist | Indiana Golden Opportunity, second place |
2016
| Murphy's Secret - Single Title | Jamestown Homecoming - Series/Category | |
| Linda Howard, first place | Linda Howard, third place | |
| Ignite the Flame, first place | Golden Rose, first place | |
| Maggie, third place | Molly, first place | |
| Fabulous Five, second place | Catherine, second place | |
| Cleveland Rocks, second place | Maggie, third place | |
| Great Expectations, third place | Fool for Love, third place | |
| Gateway to the Best, second place | Fabulous Five, first place | |
| Beacon, first place | Beacon, finalist | |
| Pages from the Heart, third place | ||